Stopping to ask for Directions
I've been tentatively wandering around the blogosphere in the last few days with a lot of patient coaching from my son. I had heard that a few editorial cartoonists have blogs, so I wanted to see what they do with them.
One of my favorite cartoonists is Mike Luckovich at the Atlanta Constitution. The energy in his work makes my adrenalin rush, and just when you've settled into his quick, one-liner sort of voice he lands a roundhouse punch to your stomach. Mike is never as simple as a reader might want to believe. If you don't know his work, I encourage you to check him out. He's reprinted everywhere -- they must keep a toothbrush for him in the Newsweek offices.
Anyway, I see that his blog mainly consists of the posting of his published cartoon each day with an invitation to vote yes or no to the question, "Do you like this cartoon?" Then the reader is invited to post a comment.
The blog gets hundreds of comments most days, and it occurs to me that maybe that's what readers really want --- just a simple means of registering their vote and a comment on the day's cartoon.
I've been enjoying posting sketchbook pages and behind-the-scenes material on my blog and have felt this might be something unique. But it occurs to me to stop to ask, "What would interest you?" Would you like to have us posting the day's cartoon with a comment prompt? Or do these over-my-shoulder napkin scrawlings interest you?
20 Comments:
I think what you're doing now is wonderful. I can see your cartoon in the newspaper or by going to the Borgman section of the Web Site. What's on here is interesting and insightful. "Do you like this cartoon?" means nothing to me personally. I could care less if anyone else likes it.
Keep up the great work!
What you are doing is great. It adds insight to the process and offers a way for your critics to see that sometimes you are really more on the same page than they thought.
One of the more interesting things the Enquirer has done lately. Please kill this creative interaction between you and your readers
Well, if I have to choose, I choose both. I enjoy the behind-the-scenes and would like to see the finished product here too if possible. (instead of digging for it elsewhere). I don't care for the yes or no vote, but leave it open to comments, yes or no is too restrictive.
Jim, what you're doing is fantastic - as others have said; it gives a great insight into the process. I do, however, think that your final cartoons should appear on the blog more often ALONG WITH the preliminary sketches. I like to see the evolution of your work from concept to finished product. The "Do you like it?" option wouldn't really interest me.
As a sidenote, I myself am an editorial cartoonist and you have inspired me to now start a blog at:
http://www.jasonchatfield.com/blog
Jim,
Comments on blogs can be a double-edged sword. Some comments can be very helpful in providing meaningfull debate as well as exposing you to other viewpoints you might not have considered. As they say a "picture is worth a thousand words" and since your medium is pictures, its intriguing to see what 1000 words everyone comes up with.
On the other hand, some people use comments to say vile, infantile, hateful things that don't further a debate but rather turn people off. Regardless of the amount of disclaimers on a website, unless you actively defend every comment flame, some readers will walk away thinking some idiot's comments have some level of tactic approval from you.
So it comes down to the amount of thick skin you have and the willingness to put up with both the good and the bad from the great Internet unwashed.
That being said, I like the idea of having a scale of 1-10 available to indicate which cartoons I like. It could be incorporated into the year in review the Enquirer...
Thanks for all the good work,
M@
Without doubt, you absolutely NEED to keep posting your sketch pages. I love seeing your thought process toward the final result. Voting...who cares? Keep up the good work!
As an illustrator and longtime fan of your work, seeing the sketches and creative process makes me look at your cartoons in a whole new light.
I'm lucky enough to own a few of your originals and I wish I could have seen the sketches for those!
I love what you are doing so far with the sketches. My only worry is you will get burnt out between the daily cartoon, the blog, and Zits. I hope that never happens because my day is not complete without the cartton and zits and now this blog is cutting into my work time. I hope my work does not block the site.
Please keep it up.
Sketches and thoughts are best. Love your Starbucks napkins!
Both! ... I'd love to see an RSS feed for your daily work. I've been a fan of yours for the last 20 years, but it's hard to keep up with you from Austin, Texas (my residence for the last five).
At the same time, it's great to see the work behind the work.
I agree with M@ - witness the recent nastiness that the WashPost's ombudsman had to endure. The Post cut off public comment to her blog because of a ridiculous argument that developed there, and the subsequent name-calling...
Give it time, and let it develop. It's a new medium, and may take some acclimation. In addition, ignore any advice you get from people like me. Our advice didn't get you to where you are now.
I'm also a long-time fan, and enjoy the backstage tour. Thank you for setting it up.
Jim,
Someone just created a syndicated feed for you at livejournal which is where I first heard of your blog.
I'm not one who normally the type of person who comments on specific comics in any of the webcomic forums or generally.
Much more interesting to me is the chance to get more perspective on what you're thinking. I echo the comments of the first poster, I really don't care whether other people think you're brilliant. It only matters that I do.
So keep doing what you're doing and don't let the lack of feedback bother you. As the site gains in popularity, you'll look back on these carefree days of a few people saying nice things, instead of a mass of people being stupid, as a mass of people is wont to do.
I love seeing the sketches and reading the blog viewers' comments. Forget the "Do you like this cartoon?" option. Besides, do you really want your editors to know people didn't like your cartoon idea? :-)
I agree with the other blogger, I'd like to see the finished product next to the sketches it was born from.
I'd also like to see some "Zits" sketches and any other stuff you're doodling.
People who follow political cartoonists, especially Pulitzer Prize recipients, enjoy seeing the cartoonist's process in creating a cartoon. The problem with Mike Luckovich's site, (asking readers if they like or dislike a cartoon), is that the debate usually degenerates into personal attacks between the conservatives and the liberals. I would like to know if you rely on looking at photographs to draw the imagery in your cartoons or if the final product comes solely from your imagination. You are very talented at drawing caricatures.
It ain't broke, don't fix it.
I'll add to the convalcade: I have no need to vote on whether I like a cartoon. Comments and sketches are lovely -- I always enjoy seeing drafts and process-oriented material.
And while it is perhaps not always available to also dislay the finished cartoon -- I have no idea if you have the rights to display something that's being simultaneously syndicated -- I think those drafts might be more accessible if they could be seen simultaneously with the version they turned into.
Perhaps simply a link to the relevant cartoon in the Enquirer, when available, would suffice.
I'm probably not your typical audience as I'm also an illustrator--but I LOVE behind the scenes stuff, sketches, process info etc...
Definitely continue with sketches thing and more...definitely. Yeah, definitely.
Jim, Keep posting your thoughts. It is great to hear more and see more about how and why you do what you do.
Although, I wonder if you could add such a function in your blog-comments as a poll each time.
Over the shoulder gives us a chance to watch an artist at work.
It shows how important the sweat is in getting the work done.
"Nothing in this world can take the place of persistence. Talent will not; nothing is more common than unsuccessful people with talent. Genius will not; unrewarded genius is almost a proverb." ~ Calvin Coolidge
* Our online blogs currently are hosted and operated by a third party, namely, Blogger.com. You are now leaving the Cincinnati.Com website and will be linked to Blogger.com's registration page. The Blogger.com site and its associated services are not controlled by Cincinnati.Com and different terms of use and privacy policy will apply to your use of the Blogger.com site and services.
By proceeding and/or registering with Blogger.com you agree and understand that Cincinnati.Com is not responsible for the Blogger.com site you are about to access or for any service you may use while on the Blogger.com site.
<< Home